Sunday, September 14, 2014

Othering!?


This photograph is from Wing Young Huie's Homelessness collection and doesn't have a date or location. At first glance the man appear to be holding out a basin for people to place money in it. He is well dressed and does not appear to be unclean. Also, he looks happy unlike the general stereotype of a homeless person. Due to his decent physical state the basin he is holding may not be for begging for money. Instead it could be for cooking or another purpose. 

By looking deeper into this photo one begins to question if this man and women are actually homeless. It is quite possible that they are actually helping homeless people. The basin could have carried supplies or food for homeless people and he was giving them away. This deeper look at the picture forces the audience to question their analysis of stereotypes. A well dressed man is stereotyped to be well off in our society; however a man sitting on the side of a road is most often poor. 

Stereotypes in this picture characterize the man as either homeless or someone who is wealthy enough to assist the homeless. In Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale, stereotypes are also used to identify the individual. The society in the book aids the stereotypes by forcing women to wear uniform clothes. The uniformity of women perpetuates there stereotypes and reinforces their role in society. Women are supposed to feel as though they are onlookers from the true influential powers of society. Their uniforms force them to feel and act this way. Their image is much like the mans image in the picture. The way he is dressed, or his image, portrays him as wealthy, therefore breaking the stereotype of being poor. 

1 comment:

  1. This image is crazy! I can't figure out what's going on- the woman and man are well-dressed (her sunglasses, his suit), but they are sitting on the ground in front of what I assume to be a store, with shopping carts around them. Did Wing Young Huie provide any sort of context?
    I was worried that you would only say that othering was presented in THT through the handmaids' clothing, but I was pleasantly surprised when you furthered your explaination by exploring how their clothing FORCES them to behave a certain way though they themselves might internally reject it.

    ReplyDelete